Unabletomakeprogresswithherex-lesbianconversionpath,aneurotic"AllAmerican"Jilltracksdownherbutchex-girlfriendJamietoprovetoherselfthatsheisnolongerattractedtoher.Strungalongbyguiltanddesire,Jamieagreestothepreposterousplanof"dating"JillsothatJillcanclosethischapterofherlifeandmoveforwardwithmen.Meanwhile,DavidandLolacompetefortheaffectionsofJosé,asexuallyambiguousandseductivemanfromBrazil,andtheycomparenotesontheirdifferingopinionsofhissexuality.AscomplicationsarisewithJillandJamie'srelationship,JillstartstoseeJoséasherticketout.However,whenthelovetrianglesshiftandrealign,Jamiehasherownidentitycrisisthatsheisill-equippedtohandle.Amixofover-the-topcomedy,sharpwit,andpathos,"HeterosexualJill"ridestheedgeoflaughterandpain,desireandrepression,andexploresthecomplicatedattachmenttoone'ssenseofselfinthefaceoflove.